Foreign Affairs; Smoking Or Non-Smoking?, by Thomas L Friedman
This is a menu of the topics on this page (click on any):
Israel's foreign minister, Shimon Peres, offers the following possibility:
Several decades ago, he notes, they discovered that smoking causes cancer. Soon
after that, people started to demand smoking and non-smoking sections. ''Well,
terrorism is the cancer of our age,'' says Mr. Peres. ''For the past decade, a
lot of countries wanted to deny that, or make excuses for why they could go on
dealing with terrorists. But after what's happened in New York and Washington,
now everyone knows. This is a cancer. It's a danger to us all. So every country
must now decide whether it wants to be a smoking or non-smoking country, a
country that supports terrorism or one that doesn't.''
As Mr. Peres himself notes, this is not a clash of civilizations -- the
Muslim world versus the Christian, Hindu, Buddhist and Jewish worlds. The real
clash today is actually not between civilizations, but within them -- between
those Muslims, Christians, Hindus, Buddhists and Jews with a modern and
progressive outlook and those with a medieval one. We make a great mistake if we
simply write off the Muslim world and fail to understand how many Muslims feel
themselves trapped in failing states and look to America as a model and
inspiration.
''President Lincoln said of the South after the Civil War: 'Remember, they
pray to the same God,' '' remarked the Middle East analyst Stephen P. Cohen.
''The same is true of many, many Muslims. We must fight those among them who
pray only to the God of Hate, but we do not want to go to war with Islam, with
all the millions of Muslims who pray to the same God we do.''
The terrorists who hit the U.S. this week are people who pray to the God of
Hate. Their terrorism is not aimed at reversing any specific U.S. policy.
Indeed, they made no demands. Their terrorism is driven by pure hatred and
nihilism, and its targets are the institutions that undergird America's way of
life, from our markets to our military.
These terrorists must be rooted out and destroyed. But it must be done in a
way that doesn't make us Osama bin Laden's chief recruiter. Because these Muslim
terrorists did not just want to kill Americans. That is not the totality of
their mission. These people think strategically. They also want to trigger the
sort of massive U.S. retaliation that makes no distinction between them and
other Muslims. That would be their ultimate victory -- because they do see the
world as a clash of civilizations, and they want every Muslim to see it that way
as well and to join their jihad.
Americans were really only able to defeat Big Tobacco when whistleblowers
within the tobacco industry went public and took on their own industry, and
their own bosses, as peddlers of cancer. Similarly, the only chance to really
defeat these nihilistic terrorists is not just by bombing them. That is
necessary, but not sufficient, because another generation will sprout up behind
them. Only their own religious communities and societies can really restrain and
delegitimize them. And that will happen only when the Muslim majority recognizes
that what the Osama bin Ladens are leading to is the destruction and denigration
of their own religion and societies.
This civil war within Islam, between the modernists and the medievalists, has
actually been going on for years -- particularly in Egypt, Algeria, Saudi
Arabia, Jordan and Pakistan. We need to strengthen the good guys in this civil
war. And that requires a social, political and economic strategy, as
sophisticated, and generous, as our military one.
To not retaliate ferociously for this attack on our people is only to invite
a worse attack tomorrow and an endless war with terrorists. But to retaliate in
a way that doesn't distinguish between those who pray to a God of Hate and those
who pray to the same God we do is to invite an endless war between civilizations
-- a war that will land us all in the smoking section.
Mr. Peres is on to something -- this sort of division is going to emerge
-- but we must be very, very careful about how it is done, and whom we, the
U.S., assign to the smoking and non-smoking worlds.
Organizations mentioned in this article:
Related Terms:
You may print this article now, or save it on your computer for future reference. Instructions for saving this article on your computer are also available.
Page Top